Rank Update

  • Minecraft Middle Earth is a Minecraft community that recreates the world described by JRR Tolkien and his writings. Everyone can participate in organized events in which we collaborate to create major landmarks, terrain, caves, castles, towns, farms and more.

    To get started, visit The New Player Guide
Rank Update
Assistant/Lead Builder Merger

What? Another Rank Change???

That's right! The Valar held a meeting (Sunday, November 11th) wherein we discussed several topics. One of these topics was the current state of the Assistant and Lead Builder Ranks. As you all know, the ranks caused quite a bit of controversy this year as they are unprecedented in the traditional MCME Rank System. So, during the meeting, in an attempt to simplify the Build Team a bit (As per requested by several staff members) we analyzed the Assistants/Lead Builders and their role/niche on MCME.
We've came to the conclusion that:


1. The two ranks on the server have too few people to constitute an individual rank alone.
2. The Assistants and Lead Builders (While diverse in responsibility) share a similar niche on the server.
3. It is more beneficial for this group to join into one Assistant Team.
4. The Assistant's Local chat is abysmal.


What this means is, instead of Artist Lead Builder, Foreman Lead Builder, and Designer Lead Builder, we will now have Artist/Foreman/Designer Assistants. Just as Raffyyy is Guide Assistant and Toti is Media Assistant. All in all, the permissions, status, and responsibilities of each person currently with holding the Assistant/Lead Builder Rank will remain the same - this is all just a means to organize our rank system better.

Getting to this Point:
In reflection on the history of these two ranks: Upon their creation there was much upset due to the oddly specific nature of the roles of the Assistants and Lead Builders. It didn't rest well with the community, and as many of you know, caused a lot of backlash. I guarantee to all of you that the Valar heard and understood clearly the points and anger that revolved around the creation of this new rank. That said, we made the decision to create these ranks and we weren't going to go back without first analyzing their use and ability on the server.


Flash forward several months and here we are reevaluating the two ranks' value and purpose on the server. We (the Valar) of course met this past Sunday. Then we brought this discussion to the Assistants and Lead Builders themselves. Once we got approval there, we discussed the decision with the Staff. Finally, we bring ourselves to this public announcement.
I understand that this decision was made without first consulting the community as a whole and for that I am deeply sorry. It has been the trend recently that any change or update such as this is met with animosity and offense which is why I address it now. This change is made in response to the dissatisfaction of the community and doesn't really change or affect the gameplay of any member save for the Assistants/Lead Builders. It is a decision made to increase the productivity of the now Assistants and help them become a more collaborative unit.


What is the Duty of an Assistant?
Before I end this announcement off, I'd like to reiterate the duties and responsibilities of each of the Assistants as this is something people have a hard time grasping. Indeed, it took me a while to give an overarching definition to the rank and I was one myself!
In short: The Assistants are a group on the server who aid and assist the management of the community.
They are each representative and responsible for a unique aspect of this management whilst also holding the duties of their underlying rank/position on the server.


@TotiGonzales Is the Media Assistant. His duties lay within managing the Media Team, Developing MCME Videos, and *GENERALLY* helping in YouTube Collaborations and Events.
@Raffyyy Is the Guide Assistant. His duties revolve around managing the Guide Rank. Updating Guide Documentation, Reviewing Guide/Badge Applications, and offering as a Second-in-Command to the Guide Team.
@Lindolas Is the Artist Assistant. His duties involve managing Artist Applications, Assigning Trial Builds, and Monitoring Artist's Projects.
@QuantaCube Is the Foreman Assistant. His duties consist of reviewing Foreman Applications, attending Trial Jobs, Managing the Foreman Rank.
@ooitsbirdo Is the Designer Assistant. His duties involve managing Designer/Build Projects on MCME. This includes checking concepts and monitoring progress and activity on projects.


In Conclusion
Thank you all for being understanding of the new change. If there are questions or concerns myself and all the Valar would appreciate hearing and addressing them. Till our next!
 
Last edited:

Comments

Fexelitche

Hardcore MCME-er
Commoner
Jul 19, 2018
150
66
12
18
The Lonely Island of Denmark
Languages
English
Danish
French (A little)
#2
Good idea merging the two roles for the sake of simplicity and functionality.
I have one question though: You have only mentioned one of each Assistant, I might have missed something that clarified this, but is there only to be 1 Assistant of each type? Seems a little... Rough. Since the role (in my understanding of it) has a lot to do and has a key part of making everything run smoothly.
 

ryttyr

Hardcore MCME-er
Commoner
Apr 22, 2014
771
1,094
28
22
Stockholm, Sweden
Languages
English and Swedish
#3
Wasn't there a kind of documentation assistant role that managed stuff like the MCME timeline, staff documentation, general documentation and other behind the scenes stuff as well? Or did I get the initial Assistant rank duties mixed up like many others?
Also, why doesn't the Enforcers have an assistant? Surely they have a lot of organising that needs doing as well?
 

TotiGonzales

Assistant
Staff member
Assistant
Developer
Donor
Foreman
Media Team
Mar 27, 2018
38
41
11
20
Languages
English, German
#4
I don't know if many noticed but we lost a couple of assistants since the creation of the rank. Since Super and lizzy left, their tasks were assigned to the remaining assistants. I believe we are still looking for replacements. It's not easy to find someone tho as these are positions that require specific skills and a certain amount of dedication.
 

ryttyr

Hardcore MCME-er
Commoner
Apr 22, 2014
771
1,094
28
22
Stockholm, Sweden
Languages
English and Swedish
#5
I don't know if many noticed but we lost a couple of assistants since the creation of the rank. Since Super and lizzy left, their tasks were assigned to the remaining assistants. I believe we are still looking for replacements. It's not easy to find someone tho as these are positions that require specific skills and a certain amount of dedication.
I noticed but never thought about what effects it had on the ranks.
 

Eriol_Eandur

Head Developer
Staff member
Head Developer
Designer
Developer
Donor
Media Team
Sep 19, 2014
1,979
3,171
93
Germany
Languages
German (native), English
#6
I believe it's best to see Assistant rank as a very flexible staff role. Assistants are assigned to additional tasks which are not part of Designer and Enforcer roles. These task are usually related to organization or documentation.
So far experience showed that these tasks depend quite a lot on the possible candidates. If a Vala wants help with organizing some stuff and has an idea who would be a good helper he might (after staff discussion) create an Assistant position for his helper. If the task is done or there is no good candidate an Assistant position might be removed again (as already happened when Lizzy and super resigned). So there is no fixed number of Assistants.
If the Artist Assistant would step down an there is no great candidate but the Foreman Assistant has a lot of time he might overtake the Artist Assistant task too.
If managing all (social) media would become too much for the Media Assistant we would maybe look for a second Media Assistant.
If the Head Enforcer would decide that he needs some help with organization of Enforcement duty roster he might look for an Enforcer Assistant
I want to stress that you can't apply for Assistant rank. It's always the initiative of a Vala to search for someone to get help. The Vala might openly ask at the forum who is interested but that is not mandatory. The Vala can also decide to privately talk to players he wants to help him.

Before we introduced Assistant and Lead Builder ranks the additional tasks like giving feedback to Artist applications or keeping documents up to date were done by Designers and Enforcers without further public notice. The additional Assistant rank just makes these additional tasks more visible and enables us to involve people who are good with organizing but not with building or enforcing.
 

Arkengard

Head Guide
Staff member
Head Guide
Mar 8, 2014
133
297
18
20
#7
As I said in my forums post, they each are representative and responsible for a unique role on the server. That said, their similarities lie in how their roles revolve around managing communal functions (generally speaking). As eriol said, these are just the jobs of the current assistants and their acting titles.
 

Arkengard

Head Guide
Staff member
Head Guide
Mar 8, 2014
133
297
18
20
#8
Wasn't there a kind of documentation assistant role that managed stuff like the MCME timeline, staff documentation, general documentation and other behind the scenes stuff as well? Or did I get the initial Assistant rank duties mixed up like many others?
Also, why doesn't the Enforcers have an assistant? Surely they have a lot of organising that needs doing as well?
As for this, super and Lizzy were they but we strongly discourage filling gaps for the sake of filling gaps.
As for the enforcer assistant, currently dyno is perfectly capable of managing the enforcer team by himself and doesn’t need that role
 

superlolster

Hardcore MCME-er
Commoner
Jul 31, 2017
359
929
38
15
Pacific Ocean
Languages
English
#11
I noticed but never thought about what effects it had on the ranks.
Basically the assistants are/were when I was one very specific to the person that was the assistant and as you can see filling the position is nearly impossible, me and lizzy did very different jobs to Toti and raff but I guess now they had to take on our work as well as theirs
 

Furuss

Aspiring Commoner
Commoner
Nov 20, 2018
9
9
7
Languages
English, Polish
#13
Haha this chart is great! Especially notes xD
 

Jonatanknalle

Foreman
Foreman
Apr 10, 2018
152
183
29
15
The great former empire of Sweden!
Languages
French
English
Swedish
#14
After much toil, I've managed to update my chart. One layer of seniority has been removed since V1 - you're on the right path @Arkengard

View attachment 12285

formally requesting a place in the wiki @BWOT
Also all assistants and enforcers can apply for badges. (And I guess Designers can apply for tours and minigames badges)
 

Will_em

Hardcore MCME-er
Mar 1, 2014
732
1,299
56
27
#16
I just wish the rank of fishslapper came into place. I'm sure Credoo would like it.
 

Arkengard

Head Guide
Staff member
Head Guide
Mar 8, 2014
133
297
18
20
#17
I just wish the rank of fishslapper came into place. I'm sure Credoo would like it.
Something we will surely look into.
Reminds me of once long ago that I seriously asked Q to create a rank called “Poop Sweeper” (essentially) who goes around and fixes derps around the map...
 

Jonatanknalle

Foreman
Foreman
Apr 10, 2018
152
183
29
15
The great former empire of Sweden!
Languages
French
English
Swedish
#18
Something we will surely look into.
Reminds me of once long ago that I seriously asked Q to create a rank called “Poop Sweeper” (essentially) who goes around and fixes derps around the map...
Sonds like something for ard :)
@Ardelenia