It makes sense geologically (as Eyjafjallajökull showed us 200mi is a laughable distance for volcano ash, not even including wind and water) and produces some great visuals.
I like the idea - even if it's just for a part of Nurn (like the Noth-West shore as the "Black Beaches")
Yes. It is also separated from the volcanic wasteland by a (pretty much) solid wall of rock. The only way surface winds or water could exit the plateau of Gorgoroth would be the opening to the South-East - into Nurn.
It makes sense geologically (as Eyjafjallajökull showed us 200mi is a laughable distance for volcano ash, not even including wind and water) and produces some great visuals.
I like the idea - even if it's just for a part of Nurn (like the Noth-West shore as the "Black Beaches")
Yes. It is also separated from the volcanic wasteland by a (pretty much) solid wall of rock. The only way surface winds or water could exit the plateau of Gorgoroth would be the opening to the South-East - into Nurn.
Some ash rains here and there of course. However if you consider possible (general) winds like the see breeze from Ethir Anduin and the wind streaming back from the valley of Rohan (from the winds caught against the Misty Mountains) pushing against the ash clouds and the Ephel Dúath you can come up with a logical explanation why the White City isn't blackened yet.
[Disclaimer: I have no idea if such wind systems would actually exist if Middle Earth was a real place, but from my amateur knowledge they don't sound illogical.]
Remember the time when I wrote an 11-post long guide on an as realistic as possible guide for the misties? Could you please stop making my work look so bad compared to this?
Remember the time when I wrote an 11-post long guide on an as realistic as possible guide for the misties? Could you please stop making my work look so bad compared to this?