Finished Rivendell Forge Poll

[_Luk]

~Rivendell Forge Poll~​

Hey Guys!

With the Reboot of Rivendell came a rebuild of the Forge, in the Time the project is already going, we made 2 new Forges:

The Forest Forge:

Note: This Forge is based on the one from Peter Jacksons Return of the King.

Pictures:

The Lore Forge:

Note: This Forge is lore accurate.

Pictures:

To include you, the community more in the Project we've decided thats its on you to decide which of those 2 Forges we should use.
You get 1 week time to choose one and after that the poll will close.

Happy Voting!

-Lukas
Edit: Time until decision is Sunday, because the Current Result is speeking for itself. No need for a longer time

 

[Indorilian]

might as well have one lore accurate thing in rivendell.

 

[nevik45]

I like how the forest one looks, but it doesn't fit in with lore or Rivendell. In a small human town it would, but not there.

 

[Fornad]

How do you define "lore-accurate"? Tolkien never described the forge in Rivendell.

 

[_Luk]

How do you define "lore-accurate"? Tolkien never described the forge in Rivendell.

well lore accurated in terms of having a house like described in the atlas

 

[Fornad]

well lore accurated in terms of having a house like described in the atlas

The Atlas isn't lore. It's a secondary source, and so both forges above are equally lore-accurate. It would be inaccurate to not have a forge at all, but that's it.

So this is a discussion about aesthetics.

 

[Top_Gun]

Having a bunch of trees growing right over a place where you're working with blazing fires and hot metal and sparks is one of the least sense-making things I can think of.

 

[Bombur8]

Arf, I love both... I'll go for the forest one, since it is not really non lore accurate and a bit more charming, but in my opinion, the best forge would be a mix of both.

 

[Portalrules333]

Forest one looks cooler, but the rest of Rivendell is basically all from the Jackson-verse. Would be nice to have one thing from the books in it.
Also, as top_gun said, all of the trees are a huge fire risk. I am sure the elves would be more responsible!

 

[nevik45]

I really think the new one is a lot better than the forest one. It fits in with rivendell, even better than the original one.

 

[_Luk]

UPDATE:

So after having this Realy clear result, I decided that waiting longer doesnt make sence really,
SO:

The Lore Forge will stay,

thx for participating